The Business Implications of Outsourcing Specialized Healthcare Functions

[noahsmithnot]

Healthcare organizations need to juggle clinical duties with the business systems that help them maintain their operations. Providers aren't just patient care specialists, they're also financial reporters, information technologists, regulators, staffing coordinators and administrators. With the complexity of these duties, it has become a strategic option for medical practices and health care organizations to outsource specific tasks.
Outsourcing is not just an outsourcing for cost-cutting. It can impact on the organization's control, service quality, financial planning, data security and capacity to meet shifting operational needs. It is important to recognise these implications to help healthcare leaders make informed decisions on whether outside or in-house management is more effective.

Understanding the Strategic Value of Outsourcing

Outsourcing is the practice of delegating certain tasks to another party, company, or organization, instead of keeping them within the company. Typically, in healthcare, these are medical billing, information technology support, payroll administration, transcription, and some administrative services.
The choice usually comes about when an organization recognizes a need in its operations – one it does not have the resources to fill. If a medical practice or clinic is getting larger, it will need more of a specialized billing knowledge than what its existing staff can reflect. You could hire more staff, but an external provider could be a way to utilize existing processes and people.
The strategic value is related to the function being outsourced. It may be appropriate to have tasks that need a specific skill or change with the amount of work. Sensitive, close patient relationships or important knowledge may lead to more internal oversight, due to responsibilities.
The aim should be to find out what operating model is most appropriate for meeting the organization's requirements, not because it's available.

Evaluating Costs Beyond the Service Fee

Cost is a key factor in outsourcing decisions but the cost of an outsourcing versus an in-house solution should not just be based on vendor quotes and payroll.
They need to recruit, offer employee benefits, train, provide software and equipment, supervise and carry out ongoing professional development for their internal team. These costs may be paid for by external providers and make some of these capacities more available to smaller organizations.
However, there are costs involved with outsourcing. It takes resources to implement this, to manage contracts, to integrate the system, to communicate, and to monitor its performance. There could also be extra fees if there is a change in requirements or services are extended beyond the initial agreement.
Any financial assessment needs to take into account the overall cost of each arrangement for a specific time period. It also needs to consider the impact of service disruption, service quality and delays that might impact other services.
The lowest cost provider may not be the highest dollar value. A slightly higher fee may be warranted if greater reliability, reporting, or access to expertise are provided that might otherwise be hard to maintain.

Medical Billing as a Specialized Business Function

Medical billing illustrates the point about the importance of making careful outsourcing decisions. It involves gathering accurate patient and insurance details, claim preparation, tracking payer responses, posting payments and investigating missed payments.
Information and working together are crucial for each stage. Errors in claims and unclosed claims can result in more time than usual being devoted by staff to finding discrepancies, rectifying claims, and communicating with insurers. The activities may have impacts on the practice's financial transparency and involve resources that could be used elsewhere.
If you are looking into hiring external support, you might want to see what medical billing services in California can offer you, as it will help you understand the different kinds of services they provide, such as claims processing, claims denial management, accounts receivable follow-up and insurance verification.
But the choice of provider doesn't just entail a comparison of service descriptions. Healthcare organizations should consider the provider's specialty experience, transparency, communication practices, technology compatibility, and their capacity to meet their needs.
The best choice is an arrangement that meets an identified operational need and that will still provide the practice with appropriate financial control.

Managing Data Security and Compliance

When sensitive data is outsourced or a party is responsible for sensitive functions that meet regulatory requirements, there are added risks that may arise from the outsourcing. Healthcare organizations need to be aware of what information a vendor can see, how this information is safeguarded and which responsibility it falls on to each party.
The U.S. Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) offers provisions to safeguard specific health information. If a service provider meets the definition of a business associate, contractual measures and requirements may be required that affect the provider.
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services has a guide on HIPAA business associates that explains these responsibilities.
Before entering into an agreement, organizations must consider access controls, security measures, how incidents are reported, employee training and what happens when the agreement comes to an end (returning or transferring the information). They should also verify that contractual conditions are in line with the services being offered.
Importantly, delegating a task doesn't mean that you can't still monitor it. Healthcare leaders need to set clear expectations of accountability and be able to track the external provider's compliance with agreed standards.

Preserving Operational Control and Service Quality

A contracting process is not enough to be successful in an outsourcing project. There should be a clear understanding within the internal team and outside the team of what is expected from the team, responsibilities, deadlines, escalation and performance.
If this is not clear, work could be duplicated, requests may not be replied to and issues could not be resolved as each party assumes the other is responsible.
Risks can be minimized if an organization documents current processes in advance of transferring responsibilities. They should then determine measurable performance metrics suitable to the services, such as turn around time, error rate, response time, reporting time, adherence to agreed procedures etc.
Routine review to help identify common issues and if the arrangement is still addressing business needs. An organization should also have a plan of transition in case it has to dissolve the relationship, with processes to transfer the records, restore the internal capabilities and ensure continuity of service.
These protections enable healthcare leaders to gain insights from outside the organization while maintaining control over operations.

Choosing Between Internal and External Capabilities

It's not an either-or situation when deciding to outsource. Many healthcare organizations thrive on a hybrid approach where their internal employees decide and execute on specific aspects of the business, but leave other aspects to experts outside the firm.
For example, a practice might send routine claims processing out for external claims activities, and handle financial planning, payer relationships, and the ultimate oversight in-house. This can give the specialists access to expertise without giving up access to the institutional knowledge or strategic control.
The mix will vary with the size of the organization, volume of work, budgets, and staff abilities. For smaller practices, they may appreciate the ability to avail themselves of features that they might not be able to afford to have in-house, and for larger practices they might want to keep functions that are integral to their business model.
These decisions need to be reviewed periodically as staffing requirements, technology, volume of services and business goals evolve.

Building a Sustainable Outsourcing Strategy

The first step in successful outsourcing is to have a well-defined business problem. Before committing, organizations should determine what they are missing, understand what the cost of doing in-house vs. outsourcing is and compare, identify potential providers, and set measurable expectations.
Rather than taking on a lot of accountability, it's better to have a small initial deployment to evaluate compatibility and service quality. The relationship is established and regular performance checks and communication can help to ensure the relationship remains valuable.
Outsourcing specific healthcare functions is ultimately a management decision that impacts more than just departments costs. It affects the allocation of resources, the protection of information and the accountability of the organization, as well as adaptation to operational requirements.
External partnerships can enhance internal expertise and help to build more resilient healthcare operations, if they are managed carefully and appropriately. The aim is to not just offload as much work as possible, but to locate every function at a place it can execute safely, securely, and with long-term goals in mind.